Some of the BEST Italian Food on Long Island

 

The Bountiful Gourmet’s The Good, The Bad and the Ugly of 2009
By Rich Branciforte

Italian Restaurants...
Mama’s …incredible deals on Mondays, lines coming out the door. Great quality, amazing quantity, Don’t miss the rigatoni carbonara…Copaigue
Fra Amichi…excellent pasta selection, good lasagna, very fine pizza selection, top notch buffalo chicken pizza…Massapequa
Spasso’s..portions so huge it’s hard to believe, take homes a must..Great chicken parm(Thursday is chicken specials), over the top pasta including the mandatory Rigatoni Carbonara and gigantic slices of pizza. Try the Chicken Marsala or Buffalo Chicken…Westbury
La Famiglia…recently redesigned, this is your home away from home. Outstanding pastas, very tender veal dishes, state of the art pizzas including a fiery Buffalo Chicken pizza with shredded chicken…Glen Cove


Spasso's 625 Old Country Road in Westbury (516) 333-6031

You could probably throw a dart at the menu and you still would come up with a good meal.  Fettuccine Alfredo is top notch, the Rigatoni Bolognese makes the taste buds dance, and the Penne Antonio is a great mix of broccoli, zucchini, sun dried tomatoes, olives and mushrooms sautéed with garlic, virgin olive oil and artichokes.  A health addicts delight…oh yeah, right.
Every Monday is pasta day, and take out orders are only $8.95 and come with salad, bread, garlic knots (excellent) and your choice of rice pudding or chocolate pudding (Take the rice, it’s dense).
Some standouts from the menu include Veal Cutlet Parmigiana, tender and tasty, Shrimp Fra Diavolo and Lasagna de Casa.
Thursday is Chicken Day and that’s when Spasso pulls out all stops.  Chicken Parmigiana is enough to feed a small regiment, and the Chicken Alla Bella Malina is a knockout.  This is chicken sautéed with mushrooms, and spinach, covered with Mozzarella cheese.  They have a dozen different selections, and all can be had for only $10.95 for takeout and comes with the same extras as on Pasta Monday.

O.K.  We’ve overloaded on carbs, that’s for sure, but how does Spasso do on the pizza test?  A big fat A, that’s how.  They have nearly two dozen selections.  How about a little lasagna pizza to get started?  Or maybe you’re in the mood for something light; the Hawaiian Pie with Pineapple and Ham is a winner.  Wish you were in Philadelphia?  Th
en the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza is for you.  Delicious.  And, my personal favorite, and the reason I haven’t tried most of the other pies, is the Buffalo Wing Pizza, a jumbo slice with fried chicken pieces (very tender), on top of blue cheese dressing and mozzarella cheese.  You can also have spicy by request.  This will set you back a meager $3.95 and easily is big enough for two.
The owners and staff at Spasso are very cordial, and will go out of their way to make your order special to your liking.  Garlic bread and knots are both the real deal.  Appetizer portions are large and you’re warned you may not have r
oom for the rest of the meal if you indulge too soon.

My suggestion is order a few different things and be prepared to bring them home and feast for days to come.
Spasso is celebrating their 50th year so they must be doing something right!
Tell them the Bountiful Gourmet sent you … burp!

Spasso Pizza in Westbury is a true treasure. In an Island awash in red sauce, sometimes, great comfort food is found in an unlikely place. Spasso looks like a thousand other pizzerias on Long Island, tucked in the corner of a non-descript strip shopping center.  That’s where the similarity comes to an end.  Spasso has more than 30 pasta dishes, each a delicious take on classic Italian cooking.  Our favorite is the Rigatoni Carbonara, a lush pasta in a white cream sauce with onions, cheese, and bacon.  Big chunks of bacon, no skimping here.  The sauce is rich, thick, and delicious.  And they don’t go overboard with the onions like many places.

The Olive Garden

The Bountiful Gourmet has been pretty busy. This of course was before the ortho suggested a sizable weight loss might go a long way to helping the knees.
But enough doom and gloom….we have food to review.
To many, the thought of going to Olive Garden for Italian food seems senseless when you consider the number of outstanding Italian restaurants we have on Long Island. Three recent visits made us a convert…there is a time and place for the Olive Garden, and one of the times is when they have their “Never Ending Pasta Bowl.”  The concept is simple, you can try as many different pastas as you want mixed with 6 different sauces. Lot’s of combinations to consider. Smart diners know that you shouldn’t load up on the unlimited salad bowl and bread but its hard to turn away from these tasty treats.  For our last visit, we brought with us 8 healthy, hungry members of the Roslyn Marching Band. They were eager and boastful, in the end, they couldn’t continue beyond the third pasta bowl.  To us pasta is pasta, regardless of the shape, but we do lean towards the penne, fettuccine and orecchiette because they have more bulk.  The key really is the sauce, and these were standouts. A Creamy Parmesan Florentine with the penne was the top of the pops, and the richness of the creamy sauce was irresistible. Second on our hits lists was the Roasted Portobello Pomodoro, a lush marinara sauce. Five Cheese Marinara was another home run.  Olive Garden also gives you the opportunity to add some meat to the heat . You can get unlimited Italian sausages or meatballs for only $1.95 extra. The sausage is big and thick, very tasty. The meatballs are a major flop. They look gray, begging the question, “Are they made from meat?” They’re very smooth, taste like store bought canned meatballs and 6 of our 8 band members either didn’t finish theirs or didn’t re-order. They all had the same comment, “Doesn’t taste like meat.”  Desserts are a good bet, especially the Zeppoli or the Black Tie Mousse Cake.  Olive Garden is a very pleasant place, well designed and comfortable. The staff is very efficient and sometimes over the top in their enthusiasm.


OUR READER'S REVIEWS:
"Eat there all the time"
- Scott and Mary

 

IL Felice
3943 Merrick Rd, Seaford (516) 809-5860
OUR READER'S REVIEWS:
My pick for favorite Italian restaurant would be Il Felice in Seaford on Merrick Rd.  It has been open for a little over a year and the food is consistently excellent.  From the warm spinach salad, wilted greens with a light dressing hinting of honey, perhaps, and crisp lardons of bacon, to the homemade, not on the menu but always available for the asking,  Sfuzi, which are tiny hankerchiefs of pasta in a chunky light brown veal sauce.  Shrimp cocktail, usually boring and typical, gets kicked up by fine, fresh shrimp, that almost burst in your mouth.  Entrees include a homey Veal Osso Buco with homemade gnocchi on the side, to fish any style you wish.  My favorite is Branzini Marechiara, which is a light red sauce with fresh mussels and clams.
Although according to congenial waitstaff, you can have anything you want.  And it's true, the owner and chef, Felice, will accomodate your every culinary whim.  For dessert, try the homemade Apple Strudel, warm, flaky, served of course, with vanilla ice cream.  Il Felice is family owned and operated.  This is not a rush, rush meal, but one to be savored slowly with a nice bottle of wine from their wine list.  Go and Enjoy!!!

-Pebblz 

 

Gino's Restaurant & Pizzeria
16 W Park Ave., Long Beach (516) 432-8193

Gino’s of Long Beach is a recent find, with incredibly tender veal cutlet and delicious and inexpensive rigatoni dishes; they also have great Italian ices and Sedutto ice cream.

We told you it was the best, now tell us.

OUR READER'S REVIEWS:
"Nice food, the family loved it"
- Vincent and the Bono family

 

City Cellar
1080 Corporate Drive, Westbury - (516) 693-5400
La Famiglia
5 School Street, Glen Cove- (516) 759-7549

A Tale of Two Pastas:

City Cellar & La Famiglia
The City Cellar Restaurant in Westbury, directly opposite Target and next to Famous Dave's BBQ, is a stunning visual achievement. Its sleek, modern look is a real knockout. Once inside, you are welcomed to a large, beautifully decorated room that has the chic of Manhattan and the smoothness of Florida. Tables are tastefully a good difference from each other, insuring not bumping in to your neighbor. The adventure begins.

Our hostess led us to a table surrounded by a few families, but mainly 20- to 30-year-old men and women, fashionably dressed and out for a good time. Groups of women validated that this is the place to be seen.

It was all downhill from here. It is unfortunate that both the food and the service doesn't match City Cellar's visual splendor. It took about 15-20 minutes for a waiter to drop by. He took the drink orders and then disappeared. Bread was brought by. It was sourdough bread and hard as a rock, both in the crust and the inside. We showed it to the waiter as we knocked it on the table for emphasis. We could have hammered nails with it.

"Sometimes they leave it out for awhile," he confessed. He made no offer to replace the bread so we made the request. A return visit brought no bread so a second request was made. This one was better, but by now we had finished the appetizers.

For appetizers, we had the mushroom and onion soup, in light cream sauce with pinot grigio. If you are a mushroom lover, this is the dish for you. It is served in a bowl that is half filled, making the soup look like a lot less than it really is.

I ordered the escargot in garlic butter, a very bland dish with no trace of the promised garlic. At $11, it was a total waste of money.

For entrees, we split our dishes. A pasta order of farfalle with Portobello mushrooms and roma and sun dried tomatoes in a pesto sauce with pignoli nuts yielded a miniscule amount of chicken pieces, which were less than bite-sized. Again, a somewhat bland dish. I had the veal and braised beef Bolognese with baby mushrooms and strands of parmigiana and rigatoni.If rigatoni goes for about 59 cents a pound retail, my portion was about 15 cents worth - an incredibly small amount of pasta. The veal was tough, and the beef was probably pureed and there was no visible meat present. The tab for each of these two disasters was $19 each.

Diners can also order the crabmeat crusted Chilean bass for $29 and a 12-ounce New York Strip steak with garlicky potatoes for a mere $34 - you've got to be kidding. This has to be one of the worst deals on Long Island.

Our waiter confessed that a Florida company owned this beautiful place. The wine display behind the bar must have 1,000 bottles. This is a fashionable, trendy place to be seen, but if it's good food you're looking for at somewhat normal prices, walk next door to Famous Dave's and order practically anything from the menu. It will be better than the City Cellar.

For those who would like to experience the ambiance, come after dining hours. For others, you may call (516) 693-5400 for reservations. The City Cellar is located at 1080 Corporate Drive in Westbury.

Just when you vow you'll never go out to eat again after a bad dining experience, you bounce back. A visit to La Famiglia Restaurant in Glen Cove restored our faith in food preparation.
No one will ever accuse La Famiglia of being sleek or chic. It is a small neighborhood restaurant on a restored School Street. What it does offer is great food and great prices - which shows you can't tell a book by its cover.

As soon as you walk through the door, you are greated by an owner and his band of merry men: "What are you looking for?" they ask. "We can make it for you."

The meal starts off with kick ass bread, both Italian and foccacia. A huge bottle of olive oil is brought to the table. Let the party begin!
The junior member of our review crew opted for a slice of pizza, huge for $2 and a plate of rigatoni in butter. A delight for $6.50.
La Famiglia offers six kinds of pasta in a variety of sauces. We ordered a plate of rigatoni carbonara. A huge plate of rigatoni, with a mountain of bacon and a small amount of onions in a cream sauce was a work of art. It was not drowned in sauce, but a beautiful mixture of ingredients. This set us back a whopping $10.50.
The other member of our crew had chicken fraincoise, an accompaniment of penne a la vodka. The vodka sauce was light and flavorful. The cheese was grated, not braised. It too was a gigantic portion which was partially carried home. This was an unbelievable $8.50.

Throughout the meal, our waiter kept asking how everything was, brought a new bread-filled dish when he saw we had demolished the first batch. Everybody in the restaurant was smiling and laughing, obviously all having the same good time as us. A veal cutlet hero that was huge and very tender set us back a big $7. This sandwich had about 50 times the veal that my veal Bolognese had at City Cellar.

When we headed out, I spoke to one of the owners, Paul, and complimented him on his food and their prices. He commented, "If you have good food, people will come back." I know I will.
La Famiglia is located at 5 School Street in Glen Cove; call (516) 759-7549.
- Rich Branciforte




EDDIE'S PIZZA
2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park (516) 354-9780
We told you it was the best, now tell us.

OUR READER'S REVIEWS:
"Best damn bar pies in the world"
- Jason

LA BELLA PALERMO
90 West Main St., Babylon (631) 321-0763
We told you it was the best, now tell us.
OUR READER'S REVIEWS:
"Fabulous food, but the wait staff is the best."
- Carl